ORPL

Editorial

Songwriter Opposes Majors’ Appeal in Copyright Reversion Case

Cyril Vetter opposes the attempt by major labels to bring before the U.S. Supreme Court the question of whether copyright reversion applies to U.S. and international rights.

The scenario in which an author can reclaim rights to a work after the expiration of a statutory term has become the subject of a dispute between Cyril Vetter and major music companies. As reported by Digital Music News, the songwriter filed a 37-page opposition to the attempt by the majors and BMG to bring the case before the U.S. Supreme Court.

What the Dispute Is About

The case concerns copyright termination — a mechanism that allows authors to terminate a transfer of rights and regain control over their works after the expiration of a prescribed term. The key question is whether such reversion covers not only rights in the United States but also international rights.

Vetter believes that the decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit does not require immediate review by the Supreme Court. In his view, it is consistent with modern licensing practices and better protects authors’ interests.

The Risk of Double Claims

One of the author’s separate arguments concerns the consequences of the majors’ position. If the reversion of rights is interpreted differently depending on the country, this could lead to conflicting claims to the same catalog in different jurisdictions.

For international contracts, this means that the territory covered by an agreement and the mechanism for reverting rights cannot be treated as secondary details. Provisions determining where a transfer of rights applies and what happens after it ends may affect control over a song even after its global exploitation.

Why It Matters Beyond the United States

The decision in the case does not directly establish rules for Ukrainian law or the local music market. However, the conflict highlights a broader problem in cross-border copyright management: the global exploitation of a work does not always imply a single, clear ownership regime.

Until the U.S. Supreme Court decides whether to hear the appeal, the central line of the dispute remains unchanged: authors insist on the possibility of regaining control over their works, while the majors challenge a broader interpretation of this mechanism.

Back to editorial