News
U.S. Supreme Court Did Not Review BMG v. Vetter Case on Reclaiming Copyrights
Because four justices recused themselves, the U.S. Supreme Court was unable to consider BMG v. Vetter. The appellate court’s decision remains in effect, allowing U.S. termination rights for longstanding copyright transfers to be applied globally.
The U.S. Supreme Court declined to review BMG v. Vetter because, after four justices recused themselves, the required quorum was no longer present. This means that the decision of the Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit remains in effect.
The case concerns a mechanism provided for in Section 304 of the U.S. Copyright Act. Under certain conditions, it allows authors to terminate longstanding transfers of rights and attempt to regain control over their works. At the center of the case was an author’s attempt to reclaim the rights to the song “Double Shot (Of My Baby’s Love).”
The appellate court’s decision recognizes that U.S. termination rights for such transfers may apply worldwide. The Supreme Court did not overturn this approach; however, its decision does not constitute a direct ruling on the operation of similar mechanisms in other jurisdictions.
For Ukrainian authors, composers, and heirs, this may be relevant if their works or old agreements are connected to U.S. copyright law. In such cases, it is worth separately examining the applicable time limits, territorial scope, and terms of the rights transfer. The application of the U.S. mechanism will depend on the specific documents and requires an individual legal assessment.