ORPL

News

Case Concerning a Sample in Travis Scott Tracks Ends Without a Decision on the Merits

The lawsuit against Travis Scott and Sony over the use of a fragment from a DJ Jimi recording was dismissed without prejudice. This does not establish a precedent regarding the sample’s protection and leaves open the possibility of refiling the lawsuit.

Digital Music News reports on the dismissal of the case against Travis Scott and Sony concerning the fragment “alright, alright, alright,” which was used in the tracks “Stargazing” and “Til Further Notice.” For the industry, what matters is not so much the outcome of this particular case as the fact that it did not answer the key question: whether such a sample is subject to separate protection and whether its use had been properly cleared.

The lawsuit was dismissed without prejudice—that is, without a final decision on the merits. The plaintiffs retain the option to file it again, while no judicial assessment of the fragment’s legal status was made. Therefore, this outcome is neither an endorsement of using the sample without permission nor a legal precedent that could be applied in other cases.

For independent Ukrainian artists and producers, the situation has practical implications. Even a short, recognizable phrase altered in pitch can become a source of claims if it originates from a specific composition or sound recording. Copyright in a musical work and rights in a sound recording may exist separately, so both levels require review.

Before release, it is worth establishing the origin of every sample, clearing the rights to the composition and recording separately, obtaining written permissions, and documenting the agreed credits. This does not determine the approach under Ukrainian law, but it clearly demonstrates the potential cost of an uncleared sample: years of litigation, distribution risks, and more difficult licensing of the track later on.

Back to editorial