ORPL

Editorial

Lawsuit Over “Never Lose Me” Finally Dismissed Due to Lack of a Signed Beat License

A U.S. court did not find correspondence, payment, and the “sold” status on TrakTrain sufficient evidence of the transfer of exclusive rights to the beat.

As reported by Digital Music News, a federal court finally dismissed Shamar Deal’s lawsuit alleging copyright infringement in Flo Milli’s song “Never Lose Me.” The case was dismissed without leave to amend, meaning the plaintiff will not be able to refile it in the same form.

The lawsuit concerned the beat “Youu,” which, according to Deal, he purchased from Gerreaux through TrakTrain in 2019 for $200 and received an exclusive ten-year license for. The beat was later allegedly used in “Ron Artest” by Babyface Ray and 42 Dugg, and that track then became the basis for “Never Lose Me.”

The key problem for the plaintiff was not the history of the beat’s use itself, but evidence of how the rights had been formalized. The court noted that Gerreaux had not physically signed an agreement transferring the rights. The correspondence, payment confirmation, “sold” status on the platform, and a document from its owner did not persuade the court that the parties had properly signed an agreement for an exclusive license.

What This Means for Beatmakers

Payment and an agreement in correspondence may confirm an intent to collaborate, but they do not necessarily prove the transfer of a specific set of rights. It is important to separately document whether the license is exclusive, the term and territory for which it applies, the permitted methods of use, and who is authorized to transfer or resell the beat.

Practical Takeaway

Ukrainian artists and producers should not rely solely on a receipt, a message in a messenger app, or a sale marker on a beat platform. Before release, it is better to have a signed document clearly describing the rights transferred and to keep it together with payment confirmations and correspondence. At the same time, this case was heard under U.S. law, so its conclusions cannot be automatically applied to Ukrainian judicial practice.

Back to editorial