Editorial
Why Bans on “Ghost” Tickets Have an Easier Time Passing Than Price Restrictions
In the United States, lawmakers are increasingly separating ticket-market reforms: bans on selling nonexistent or not-yet-purchased tickets have a better chance of being enacted than strict resale price restrictions.
A Digital Music News report shows that the central battle over ticket-market reforms in the United States is not limited to restrictions on secondary-market prices. A separate and often more successful approach has been to ban speculative sales—when a ticket is listed for resale before the seller has actually purchased it, and sometimes even before such a seat officially exists.
Why Price Restrictions Are Stalling
Despite high-profile campaigns, broad bills imposing markup limits have failed to pass in major concert states. In California, the California Fans First Act failed; among other provisions, it would have capped resale prices at 10%. In New York, the Affordable Concerts Act, which would have introduced resale at face value, did not make it out of committee.
Large markets attract significantly more lobbying resources from resale platforms. The report states that StubHub alone spent $2.6 million in California opposing a bill to limit prices. Such pressure makes it more difficult to pass reforms that directly affect the secondary market’s business model.
A Narrower Law Has Better Chances
Against this backdrop, bans on “ghost” tickets appear more politically acceptable. Similar provisions are already in effect in Arizona, Connecticut, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, Nevada, North Carolina, Oregon, Vermont, and Washington, D.C.
California’s AB 1349 initially sought to explicitly ban the sale of speculative tickets. After late amendments, it lost the support of part of the music industry: critics believe the changes weakened audience protections and created advantages for large platforms. At the same time, the bill retained requirements for secondary marketplaces to prevent such sales and is now awaiting a decision from the governor.
A Lesson for Reformers
California’s experience suggests that separating controversial measures can improve their chances of passage. Banning the sale of a ticket the seller does not possess has a clearer connection to consumer protection, while price restrictions immediately affect the economics of the entire secondary market.
However, a narrower law does not guarantee a strong outcome. Lobbying can alter the wording, add exceptions, or leave loopholes—including in the federal TICKET Act, where “concierge services” could potentially make it possible to offer a ticket-purchasing service without guaranteeing that the ticket exists at the time of payment. Therefore, effective protection depends not only on the existence of a ban, but also on the precision of its definitions and the accountability of platforms.